Gun Reports - News
These were the panel's comments on reliability.
GAO Denies Sig Sauer Protest on ATF Gun Testing Results
August 24, 2010Printer Friendly | Email |
(GunReports.com) -- The Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently denied a protest from Sig Sauer, Inc., that complained that ATF didn't rate the company's guns fairly during an evaluation process.
Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson, and Glock were competing for a contract to supply the ATF with a new handgun system, according to a GAO document released Aug. 18.
According to the GAO report, "ATF is seeking to replace its current metal-frame handguns with a new .40 caliber, polymer-frame handgun system. This system consists of two handguns, which are issued to each ATF agent: a standard-size duty weapon for enforcement operations and a compact model for backup and auxiliary needs; the two models are in all other respects required to be identical in function and design."
During phase two of a three-phased evaluation process, the ATF asked 20 of its agents to put all three proposed handguns through identical live-fire tests.
Based on the results of the shooting tests, the [test shooters] recommended to the contracting
These were the panel's general assessment rankings.
The biggest problem: ATF agents had recorded 58 stoppages with Sig Sauers full-size and compact pistols, 13 of which were considered to be gun-induced and 45 shooter-induced. The report said further, "In contrast, the agents recorded a total of 16 shooter‑induced stoppages for Smith & Wesson's guns and 7 shooter-induced stoppages for Glock's guns. There were no gun-induced stoppages recorded for the Smith & Wesson or Glock guns."
To read the GAO report, click here.Reader Comments
It's unclear to me what the basis was form SIG's protest. This information is not clear in the article. Essentially, it's: "What's the complaint?"
I read the liked report and I would concur with the final decision. Sig complained that the SSB used the high number of stoppages as a criteria over other comments. Well, duh... if my life is on the line, a stoppage could be fatal and I would appreciate the fact that this criteria was given a very high value. Think about it...
As a smith and knowing all these guns, I just can't see how Sig got that many stoppages? maybe they did but Sigs are so reliable, I just see how during these test they got the stoppages. lcj
Does anybody know which pistols were tried?
Retired Military and Civil Service.
The Sig P-250. Maybe Sig should stay away from polymer framed handguns. Apparently the P-250 is as reliable as the Mosquito.
|
An Important Note for GunReports.Com Readers: Our goal on this website is to foster a free expression of views while reining in language that crosses the line of civil discourse. Accordingly, the comments areas are intended to expand the knowledge of all users of this site. But site administrators wish to discourage the use of profanity, insults, disrespect, the advocacy of lawlessness, violence or sedition, or attempts to impinge on the rights of others. While GunReports.Com encourages robust discourse that furthers our understanding of all the issues affecting gun owners, comments that break GunReports.Com’s rules will be removed. In addition, we reserve the right to edit or delete individual comments, and in extreme cases, to ban commenters at our discretion. --Tim Cole To post a comment you must be a registered user of gunreports.com and be logged in. Use one of the forms below to login or register for FREE to gunreports.com
|



